Season 1

The investigation begins. Charise Lantigne is interrogated by Ava Ledger about the dissapearance of her friend Taylor Nolan, and how worrying it was for both her and Taylor's mother. Once the interrogation is finished and Charise has left, a familiar face enters the room. Note: Sean_27 is this episode's guest animator.

The investigation just begun. A frightened Parker Robins is interrogated about watching his colleague Charlotte Stern suddenly vanish right in front of him. Barely anyone believes him, not even the police station he went to the morning after the dissapearance. Note: Mammalfriend is this episode's guest animator.

The investigation is progressing. Garrett Dennis is interrogated about the dissapearance of his colleague Amelia Euler. He discusses going past her class to refill his water bottle, and once he came back she was nowhere to be found. Unlike the other previous two who have been interrogated, Garrett wasn't too worried by this occurence. Note: fabric is this episode's guest animator.

The investigation is still going. A shy and quiet Kylie Harding is interrogated about the dissapearance of her colleauge Bryce Hansen. Although they don't talk much and Bryce was only gone for a week, it seemed as if a lot had happened judging from his change of behaviour. Note: Jonni Peppers is this episode's guest animator.

The investigation isn't going that well. Alice Howling is interrogated about the "supposed" disappearance of her son Charlie Howling. Alice already seems a little irritated from the start of the interrogation, but as it progresses we see how absurd Alice feels this is. She assumes that they are likely interrogating every single person who has a tomato baby. Once the interrogation ends, she gladly leaves the room and another person, who is also a tomato like Alice Howling, enters the room. Note: ThatPerson (the voice of Backpack in the original show) is this episode's guest animator.

The investigation is over. Owen Thompson is interrogated about the disappearance of his longtime friend Liam Plecak. He explains he doesn't know anything, and he seemed completely fine the last time he saw him. Once the interrogation ends, we cut to camera survelliance of Ava and Taylor discussing about the case closing. As the camera zooms out, a shocking truth is revealed.